ballet blog with occasional diversions

NYCB Jewels 9/20 & 9/21
Loaded with gems

        New York City Ballet dressed itself to the hilt with two more glistening performances of Jewels on Wednesday and Thursday. Every single debut was a 100 carat diamondized beauty set among the polished performances of gems including Ashley Laracey in Emeralds, Tiler Peck with Roman Mejia and Emily Kikta in Rubies, and Joseph Gordon in Diamonds. 

        Thursday evening Haglund became lost in Emeralds — spellbound, transported into an unblinking hypnotic state by Mira Nadon and Davide Riccardo and their rapport galore. There was something spiritual about this pair, an enhanced connection perhaps, that added to the fascination of this plotless work. And while it is tempting to focus here on Nadon’s luxurious style and mesmerizing movement, we have to say that our attention was drawn time and time again to Riccardo’s beautiful leg lines, generous arabesques, and articulate feet. We really need to see more of him in Balanchine’s principal roles. 
 
        Contrast this performance with the night before when Ashley Bouder embarrassed both the company and choreographer. Never have we seen such a swollen ballerina in a principal role at New York City Ballet. Never have we seen NYCB allow one egomaniac to soil Balanchine the way Bouder did on Wednesday night with her unprofessional appearance and her substandard dancing. And the air-biting to show what a glorious time she was having while flapping and jiggling her arm-flesh was just too much. She looked and danced like she was making a bid for a Jardiance commercial where the happy, fat lady celebrates how wonderful it is to be obese and how we should all normalize fatness. Frankly, we’re sick and tired of this dancer's selfish, toxic, ego-driven effort to push her way around a ballet company where she no longer fits. The constant excuse of her “possibly career ending” injury is worn down to its threads, and the ongoing use of her child as a shield from criticism is disturbing, to say the least. Bouder’s time is up. 
 
        We have to criticize NYCB management for allowing Bouder to bull her way onto the stage and for risking injury to a world-class artist like Chun Wai Chan by pairing him with Bouder and exploiting his good-sport nature. The effort it took for him to swing Bouder into the air looked like an invitation to a hernia. 
 
        Wednesday’s Emeralds wasn’t a total loss due to the exquisite performances of Ashley Laracey and Peter Walker. Laracey’s Keatsian sensuousness is the most beautiful we’ve ever seen in this role on NYCB’s stage. The generosity of her port de bras, the arch of her back, and her regal silhouette are breathtaking. Walker was perfection as a partner — gallant, attentive and strikingly beautiful in his lines and noble carriage. 
 
        Wednesday evening’s Rubies with Tiler Peck, Roman Mejia and Emily Kikta was thrilling from minute 1 to 19. Some years back when Tiler debuted in this role, Haglund thought it was a misfire. But her performance this week showed a wonderfully spirited, exceptionally fit, glowing artist who mined Rubies to extract and reveal her treasured musicality. Mejia came completely uncorked in the Villella role. His go-for-it-what-the-hell enthusiasm in this lines-don’t-matter role was so charged with electricity that it was almost fatal — he nearly killed us. The addition of Emily Kikta’s Tall Girl into this mix – well, it was definitely time to call the ambulances. She battement-ed her legs through the air like they were paddles at The Pleasure Chest.  
 
        Thursday’s Rubies celebrated a debuting cast of Emma Von Enck, Jovani Furlan, and Christina Clark. Sass-sational Emma with her aculeate feet and prickly charm ran away with this ballet. Jovani took a very good first stab at his role although he seemed less comfortable with the character portrayal than with the steps. Christina’s Tall Girl was in the mold of Tess Rechlein’s cool, confident interpretation with a coy ready-for-play aspect. The gasp-inducing length of her legs and the speed with which she could wield them was astonishing. She had all the technique, all the equipment, and all the confidence needed to deliver this role which has suddenly become the focal point of Rubies thanks to a bevy of strong new interpreters like Kikta, Nadon and LaFreniere. Looking forward to more from her.
 
        The performances on Wednesday and Thursday gifted us with two new remarkable Diamond ballerinas — each so different yet so unmistakably right for the role. Unity Phelan was quite introspective but lovely nonetheless. This role was originally made for the most introspective Balanchine ballerina ever. One rarely got to gaze into the eyes of Farrell or crack her sense of privacy. That characteristic works well in Diamonds. We kept watching Unity Phelan and thinking that this is the way it was intended. Her technique has steadily gained strength and it was difficult to find any glaring technical weaknesses in her performance on Wednesday. However, she may never be a favorite of those who have become addicted to the excesses in Sara Mearns' highly individual interpretation and who consider any Diamond not like her to be a flawed gem. Also a different Diamond was Isabella LaFreniere whose orthodox technical foundation and verticalness allowed for another distinctive interpretation — one with more regal ballerina authority. The breadth of her movement and the sweep of her limbs were stunning in this ravishing debut opposite Chun Wai Chan (also debuting) who likewise is a more orthodox trained dancer. His solos were gorgeous in form, grace, spin, and articulation. His partnering was sublime.
 
        The Thursday evening Jewels was loaded with excitement and artistic growth — all of it an immense pleasure to witness. But the one performance which we keep replaying in our minds is that of Ashley Laracey’s Emeralds on Wednesday. Our H.H. Pump Bump Award, courtesy of Manolo Blahnik, is bestowed upon her. 
 
Image 9-23-23 at 5.44 PM

 
 
 
 

NYCB Opens its 75th Anniversary Season 9/19

        Opening Night of New York City Ballet’s 75th Anniversary Season had a circusy feel to it – as though we had somehow stumbled into the middle of Massine’s Parade. A line of picketing musicians oompa oompa-ed up and down the sidewalk in front of Lincoln Center while onlookers spooned gelato into their mouths and divided their attention between the picketers and the video art installation hanging on the front of the Koch Theater. 

        Once inside the theater, however, the lucent genius of Balanchine’s Jewels was everyone’s focal point – everyone including the more than 200 NYCB alumni who came to town to celebrate the company’s diamond jubilee. 
 
        The cast of Emeralds included principal debuts by Indiana Woodward and Tyler Angle who proved to be an unlikely couple but danced well. We look forward to Indiana’s subsequent performances where we can expect more musical shading and the luxuriant texture that we love to see in her dancing. It’s impossible not to appreciate Tyler’s partnering skills, but they come at a cost which may now be too high to pay. The combination of bulk & baldness distracted us from Indiana’s elegant efforts. 
 
        Emilie Gerrity and Adrian Danchig-Waring were pointe-walking perfection in their PdD – a wonderful match in terms of tone, artistry, and refinement. They could have been walking down a path under lit lamps in Central Park like so many couples do. 
 
        The trio of Sara Adams, Sebastian Villarini-Velez and Brittany Pollack was vibrant and buoyant. The corps de ballet was school-like and uncertain about their marks but we immediately noticed Sarah Harmon’s new peaceful confidence and long elegant lines.
 
        The Rubies cast couldn’t help but strut its best stuff to Stephen Gosling’s brilliant playing of Stravinsky’s Capriccio for Piano and Orchestra. What a romp by Megan Fairchild, Anthony Huxley, and Mira Nadon! Fairchild, cheeky & flirty with chop-busting technique, knocked out the funny turns with elbows down and wrists limp as though she could have been holding a martini at the same time. Huxley, who in recent seasons has become a much more relaxed and vibrant performer while delivering his impeccable technique, offered just the right amount of showiness to compliment Fairchild’s performance.
 
        What is there left to say about Mira Nadon’s Tall Girl soloist with all the little guys clamoring around her? She made each one think they had a chance when in fact none did. As she baited her way off the stage with one risky arabesque penché after another, it was clear that her evening plans included bigger fish. This Tall Girl could battement her leg to her nose and swipe a guy's wallet at the same time. She had the club patrons gladly emptying their pockets to see her whack an attitude foot to the back of the head and throw in a few dizzying pirouettes.
 
        Sara Mearns and Russell Janzen gave out-sized performances in Diamonds. Janzen had a stamina and forcefulness in his dancing that we haven’t seen in several years and which made the prospect of his retirement this week all the more sad. Mearns has tamped down the excessive emotional output in the ballerina role and seemed particularly strong and secure in her own dancing. While each dancer was individually appealing for different reasons, they didn't particularly compliment one another although their love for dancing together was palpable.
 
        The Diamonds corps de ballet had some obviously ragged moments last evening – lines along the left side of the stage were particularly abhorrent at times. Some of the men didn’t seem to know where they were supposed to be. However, the corps women who performed the demi roles: Olivia Boisson, Christina Clark, Meaghan Dutton-O’Hara, and Mary Elizabeth Sell were magnificent.
 
        At the conclusion of Jewels, the 200+ alumni gathered on stage in front of the current company members to take bows. Edward Villella and Allegra Kent, grasping their canes and each other, were among the many stars present last evening who catapulted NYCB to the forefront in the 20th Century. In 25 years at the 100th Anniversary, Mearns, Janzen, Fairchild, Huxley, Danchig Waring, Gerrity, Nadon, Woodward, and Angle will be among those standing in front as ones who helped move the company's level of dancing into the 21st Century. What a party that will be for those of us who can hang on to make it.
 
        The H.H. Pump Award, an Acquazzura cocktail sandal with (un)caged vamp at Bergdorf’s for $1450, is bestowed upon Megan Fairchild for the standard-setting quality and charm of her performance in Rubies on this opening night.
 
Image 9-20-23 at 10.46 AM
 
 

observations 9/14

Here's the NYCB cast sheet for Week 2 that is posted in the lobby. No changes yet to Week 1.

IMG_6476

        Just curious — who out there in NYC currently receives free individual health insurance from his employer? According to NYCB, the musicians have received free individual health insurance for many years and are the only NYCB employees who do not currently pay any part of their individual health insurance premiums. Haglund's experience over the past three decades has been to pay as much as 80% of the cost of health insurance and never less than 50%. Right now, he pays $165 per month for Medicare coverage and an additional premium for prescriptions. Why in this day and age should the NYCB orchestra expect free health insurance when that would surely mean that their cost would be factored into the premiums of other NYCB employees?

        And why is the orchestra arguing a comparison with 2019 wages? 2019 is history. Everybody suffered financially in 2020 & 2021, and nobody – especially those who had to start over multiple times in new jobs – had a sense of entitlement to 2019 wages.

        Haglund's sense is that both sides in this contest are probably lying to some extent which is why neither side will release to the public the actual salaries & benefits paid. IMO, as a nonprofit organization that relies on the generosity of its supporters and the aid of government, NYCB & the union should release lists of salaries & benefits with names redacted so that the public knows where to place its sympathies.

        Every time there is a hike in ticket prices or facility fees or service fees, we should wonder why the orchestra members do not pay health insurance premiums.

        Lastly, why don't all the Lincoln Center resident companies and their unions have enough muscle to collectively negotiate favorable health insurance premiums for the many thousands of employees?

 

observations 9/12

This is a drop dead gorgeous coffee table book. Oh my goodness. While the choreography for which these costumes were designed was mostly forgettable — with the exception of the brilliant Spectral Evidence by Angelin Preljocaj, Polaris by Myles Thatcher, and Belles Lettres by Justin Peck — the costumes were nearly always a hit. We've always wondered why the Fall Fashion Gala tradition is said to have begun in 2012 when, in fact, Stella McCartney contributed major designs the previous fall.

The costumes are glorious, the photography is stunning, and the textual feel of the book is rich. On Amazon.

IMG_6473

Haglund's all-time, forever favorites by Valentino (ohhh to touch that silk):

IMG_6468

 

observations 9/5

        So . . . along with today's announcement of some fairly interesting casting for New York City Ballet's opening week of Jewels came the announcement that the NYCB Orchestra has authorized a strike in the event that contract negotiations stall. Nothing's ever easy in this city. Let's hope that everyone stays calm and focused and continues to negotiate in good faith so that we can enjoy a wonderful 75th Anniversary Season. Rather than anyone screaming and threatening, why not make the artists' salaries public so that the public can make a judgement about where to place its sympathies. No names — just a list of salaries & benefits.

        We're extremely happy with the many upcoming debuts, particularly seeing Mira Nadon and Davide Riccardo together in Emeralds; Emma Von Enck, Jovani Furlan, and Christina Clark in Rubies along with Isabella LaFreniere and Chun Wai Chan debuting in Diamonds — all will be spectacular. The casting of Ashley Bouder in Emeralds is simply indicative of a problem unresolved. A month ago she was performing out West:

Bouder summer 2023

        The Verdy role in Emeralds requires lovely arms. Luckily we'll see the most beautiful arms on the stage when Ashley Laracey performs the other principal role in the same cast. The differences in fitness and stage readiness will be both startling and troubling. Are we looking forward to seeing Tootsie Rolls waving around to Faure's lovely music in the Verdy role? Afraid not. But that isn't Bouder's concern. So long as she can count on five people sitting in the front row right corner cheering her on, she will soil Balanchine from one end of the stage to the other.

 

observations 8/28

        Smart move by ABT to upload its casting earlier than in years past. Had hoped to see some principal casting for Curley, Frenette, Klein, and Ishchuk. They may show up in underpants in Petite Mort but would rather see them suited up in the royal regalia of Ballet Imperial and Etudes.

        Cornejo, Bell, and Roxander in the more virtuosic solo in Etudes should be electrifying if they all can get those arabesque legs up and hang onto their double tours. Remembering Ahn's bravery in his knock down, death-defying Ali in Le Corsaire a few years back made Haglund think that he'd be pegged for this role, but he'll be fine in the other role in both the second and third casts. Hopefully, Cornejo, Bell and Roxander will understand that the audience won't care if they accelerate the double tours past the tempo; just get the damn eight in — or do nine if there's time. Not sure what to expect from the corps which generally gets from Point A to Point B cleanly in white acts, but needs to dance from Point A to Point B in the Etudes finale. Fingers crossed. So happy to see Devon Teuscher leading opening night.

        It will be great to see Michael de la Nuez's beautiful jumps as Olga's Fiance in On the Dnipro, but it's a shame that room couldn't be made for Eric Tamm's reprisal of the role, too.

        Shevchenko, Royal, and Misseldine in Ballet Imperial on a program with Cassandra Trenary and Aran Bell in The Dream will make for two glorious performances.

        Not much to complain about; so, we won't. Tickets on sale Wednesday, September 6th at noon.

 

observations 7/19

ABT's Fall Season just might satisfy Haglund's white tutu tooth.

Etudes and Ballet Imperial, along with The Dream, On the Dnipro (sic) (isn't it Dnieper?), Piano Concerto #1, and Petit Mort sound like a fabulous season. Basically, this is what we want.

Etudes hasn't been danced by ABT in 15 years — why? It's a favorite the world over. Expecting a stunning technical display from Devon Teuscher!

Below is a video of the Mariinsky in a miraculous finale of Etudes. Tereshkina, Sarafanov, Shklyarov. Look at the height of the back legs on those men in their jumps — principals and corps. They're killing it, and Sarafanov is simply unmatched. And Tereshkina is a goddess in pointe shoes. However, it does seem that some of the corps have difficulty jumping down instead of jumping up on the diagonals. Still and all, a standard setting finale.

Let's go let's go let's go Bell, Curly, Ishchuk, and Frenette!!

 

Tickets on sale September 6th.

 

ABT 7/13 & 7/14
Opulent Odettes and Dazzling Odiles

        Sometimes pathological optimism just bubbles up like it did this past week during ABT's performances of Swan Lake at the Met Opera House. At the moment it seems like the company has a few Odette/Odiles who are at the very height of their formidable artistic powers and who have suddenly helped ABT recover its reputation in this classic. We caught a couple of them, Skylar Brandt and Devon Teuscher, who are developing their individual interpretations at astonishing speed with the assistance of private coaches who, themselves, were memorable in the roles.

        In Skylar Brandt's Odette, we felt the emotional intensity of Irina Dvorovenko. In her Odile, we recognized the diabolical cunning with which Irina used to sashay around the stage. This year the artistry in Brandt's Odette rose to the level of her Odile. We could not decide which character we liked more or who we wanted to win in the end. Odile powered her seductive arrogance with showy balances and dominatrix-inspired whipping fouettes. She came at Prince Siegfried with a diagonal of step-over turns that made him dizzy with heat. This year, Brandt's Odette possessed a new eloquence through her lengthened front of neck and delicate clavicle. The lifted face beautifully conveyed her plight and sorrow as did her sensitive port de bras.

    Herman Cornejo as Siegfried, although technically unsteady at the start, delivered a powerfully danced and nuanced performance of his character who was so lost in love that he couldn't see straight. Cornejo surely senses the curtain slowly descending on his career and is driving hard for performances that are as memorable for their dramatic impact as his early performances have been memorable for their technical brilliance.

        Devon Teuscher, whose Odette and Odile are being developed by Isabelle Guerin, has already achieved such mastery and majesty that it is hard to imagine where she will take these characters in the future. Odette's melancholy ran so deeply at this performance and her river of tears unleashed such a torrent of despair that she might have headed for the cliff in Act II instead of waiting for Act IV. The beautiful length of back and stately shape of arabesques seemed exquisitely suited for Odette. Her character's vulnerability was steeled with an underlying strength that she didn't even know she had. It must be remarked that Devon's choice to spot the audience on her blistering chainé turns (instead of spotting the corner) sent the dramatic pulse beat soaring.  Those haunting eyes burned across the footlights. Such a great, great addition to a powerful interpretation. Also, Odile's fearsome fouettes shot straight to the side without first opening front – the effect was a faster rotation which made her seem more reckless and dominating. All of this awesome power was coupled with elegance of line and pristine positions of the feet.

        The initial Siegfried, Cory Stearns, managed his customary Act I which is to say that the basics got done but little else was accomplished. Apparently he injured his back early on which necessitated withdrawing at the end of Act II. Before doing so, however, he securely partnered Devon in a glorious White Swan PdD. 

        Aran Bell stepped in as Siegfried for Acts III and IV and made sure that it was an evening we would not forget. There may have been a slight unease in his face when he first sat down next to The Queen Mother. No doubt he was wondering if the audience was wondering what he was doing there. (We would later find out that some audience members didn't even know that a substitution had been made or that a different dancer wasn't actually supposed to dance in the last half of the show.) Bell found Siegfried's character fairly quickly without the benefits of dancing Acts I & II. He soared through the dances in The Great Hall with ease. At the conclusion of one variation, he ripped a pirouette that revolved past the music and stuck him on balance with his back to the audience. He then blasted through the Black Swan PdD on full power – not only delivering his own miraculous leaps and turns but also heaving Odile high in her arabesque fouettes and spinning her silly. His Act IV Siegfried was despondent and tormented as he lost Odette to the swampish von Rothbart and lost control of his own destiny. When Odette committed to ending von Rothbart's control with a leap to her death, Bell's chase after her and his dive off the cliff became the exclamation point of the evening. It was terrific theater in every way.

        On Thursday and Friday nights, respectively, Andrii Ishchuk and Jarod Curley danced the role of the Act III von Rothbart with convincing, conniving authority. These are two huge dancers who move with the graceful strength and speed of panthers. They gave terrific performances which brought electricity to the ballroom like we haven't seen since the days of Gomes and Malakhov. Both will undoubtedly transition into the role of Siegfried, but for now we are fortunate to have them on stage in this iconic role.

        The PdT, which in the days of Cornejo/Reyes/Cornejo was thrilling beyond words, was rather disappointing on Thursday and Friday nights. It seems that flying assemblés with sixes are beyond the ABT corps women, and consecutive sixes in place are troublesome as well. Doing "one and run" is no big challenge. Go to 8'15" here and look at what flying sixes and entrechat sixes should be at ABT.

        It was a thrilling two nights of Swan Lake. Nearly everyone deserves an H.H. Pump Bump Award, but we need to single out Devon Teuscher for her brilliant and heavenly detailed Odette & Odile with this Manolo Blahnik swan stiletto.

Image 7-18-23 at 5.41 PM

       

 

ABT 7/11
Swan Lake shocker

        It’s not easy to shock ole Haglund in Swan Lake. But Tuesday night’s ABT performance stirred up the lake's tranquility when Hee Seo sculled through an Act III Odile that actually crested above her Act II Odette. Her Prince Siegfried, Aran Bell, who is a dozen or so years her junior, gave a startlingly brilliant performance from his authoritative entry at the top of the staircase in Act I to his dramatic death dive off the cliff at the end of Act IV. Did having a fresh young pup for a partner perk up Hee to be a little more lively? Actually the fresh young pup also happens to be the franchise quarterback. And this Aran was so much more watchable than that other scraggly-faced Aaron that the Post’s sports columnists can’t stop gushing over. He danced with a boldness, freshness, and confident classicism that rarely went awry. His leg and arm lines were as clear as – ahem – a bell, and his aerial positions were pristine. He committed to the mime and made it no less meaningful than his allegro.

        Hee’s Odette began Act II with timid reserve. Her entrance wasn't the perfection that she’d planned but she steadied her center to bring forward a nicely shaped pique arabesque. There was a sense that while her legs, arms, and torso were ready to dance, she had not warmed up emotionally for Odette. Her positions were pretty; the transitions were smooth; the shapes of the supported pirouettes were beautiful. While Hee may not possess the long arms we associate with Odette, she used them elegantly and spared us any excessive flapping. Everything was lovely, but there was a remoteness that prevented the viewer from connecting with her.
 
        Hee's remoteness evaporated in Act III when Odile arrived in shimmering black on the arm of Joo Won Ahn’s seductively wicked von Rothbart. Maybe she indulged in a can or two of Red Bull at intermission because here we suddenly had a character alive with impulse and motive and full of scamp. Odile found such joy in toying with Siegfried and conspiring with von Rothbart. Ahn had full control of his evil character but unfortunately didn’t have full control of the Hungarian Princess, Anabel Katsnelson, on a lift that went glaringly wrong. It definitely spooked the young corps dancer who displayed a panicky expression as she quickly walked out of the calamity. At least Ahn didn’t drop her on her back and then trip over her like he did to Veronika Park early in his career. Ahn danced a commanding solo in full character brimming with confidence and with sharp legs that sliced through the grand allegro. Like the best von Rothbarts, he gave up a bit of tidiness for theatrical effect. (Recall Hallberg’s sensational debut as von Rothbart with his splayed fingers and throw-away grand jetes entournents.) 
 
        The Black Swan PdD did not disappoint. Bell’s gyroscope-like ability to keep his center was remarkable. He has continued to add layers of color and detail to his Siegfried who on this night was a satisfyingly complex character, not a poster-Siegfried. We should cherish his 90° arabesque and pray that he takes care of it over the next decade. The grand jetes, coupe jetes, and pirouettes were simply breathtaking in their scope.
 
        Hee’s Odile variation didn’t include a bunch of bells & whistles — just basics, which for the most part were cleanly and confidently danced. Her variation began with a double en dehors pirouette and single en dehors turn in attitude. She fought for the finishes which is something that she hasn’t necessarily been known for doing over the past decade. Her turns a la second and renverses in attitude were lovely and clear. Those fouettes were a happy surprise. Fast singles that traveled forward, and as she came downstage her expression of wicked determination came into focus. She got close enough to 30-32 to get a pass, and finished with authority.
 
        Hee was far more emotionally invested in her Act IV Odette than she had been in Act II. She was quite the captivating portrayal of distress and commitment that even overcame the shortcomings of the staging. Bell, too, was deeply invested even though he had to deliver all those big lifts after an entire night of taxing dancing.
 
        Carlos Gonzales defined his Benno with accomplished, authoritative mime and supercharged pirouettes that included unusually high retiré positions. Obviously so talented, Gonzales has also been prone to injury, and the effect shone in the areas of stability and grand allegro. We’d love to see him continue to progress in soloist roles but have also observed that Patrick Frenette needs more of a show of confidence by management. His pristine lines and noble bearing were unmistakable within a large group of corpsmen. He has obviously been putting in the work to polish his dancing, and we need to see that highlighted in a leading principal role sooner than later.
 
        The PdT in Act I was danced by Gonzales, Zimmi Coker and Breanne Granlund. It was okay, but nothing great. Zimmi was accurate and full of energy whereas Breanne displayed poorly shaped feet, missed beats on the cabrioles and struggled with the speed. She was replaced in the PdT in Act IV by Léa Fleytoux, a sparkling jewel of a ballerina.
 
        Luigi Crispino and Tyler Malone held their own in the Neapolitan dance, but only Crispino delivered the showmanship that the dance demands. The Two Swans, Chloe Misseline and Sunmi Park, jumped impressively. The Cygnettes (Fleytoux, Hannah Marshall, Rachel Richardson, Kotomi Yamada) were accurate, but were also distracting in their physical differences, like they were assembled from other quartets and thrown together for this performance.
 
        The best that can be said about the swan Corps de Ballet is that they moved together in military fashion but without the flowing beauty that one always hopes to see. The dancers were of such different sizes and shapes that it sometimes prevented the viewer from looking at the corps as a single body instead of a bunch of individual dancers. ABT needs to standardize the makeup of this corps. Some swans were as bland as if they were in a tech rehearsal whereas others were overdone with Kitri-like eyebrows and excessively black rimmed lids. At least everyone could wear the same color of lipstick, couldn’t they?
 
        We’re going to catch a couple of more Swan Lakes this week including Devon Teuscher’s on Friday night. Hopefully her Siegfried will show some life. By the way, we did manage to see Devon’s Giselle and were thrilled with her classic interpretation and the beauty of her port de bras. She showed the most elegant back and neck lines in her arabesques. Her conveyance of Giselle’s ethereal spirit was stunning in its beauty. Her Albrecht was Aran Bell, a perfect match, and together they transported the audience into their magical realm and provided the aesthetic pleasure that we all actually pay to see.
 
        The H.H. Pump Bump Award is bestowed upon Aran Bell who has been a sight to behold from every angle of every role performed thus far this season.
 
Image 7-13-23 at 9.19 AM
 
 
 
 

ABT Like Water For Chocolate 6/27
It just depends on what you’re hungry for. Really.

        There was a time when ABT’s audience members did not frequently go to NYCB performances, and vice versa, because they were hungry for different things. ABT’s audience feasted on the big spectacle dramas while NYCB’s audience wanted highly-seasoned steps, speed, and energy. That’s not really the case any more. Many, if not most, of the core audience members gorge themselves on the offerings of both companies. These days balletomanes want it all — a full course meal of spectacle, drama, steps, and energy. Expectations are high, as they should be, because ticket prices are so high.

 
        ABT’s new full length ballet Like Water For Chocolate by Christopher Wheeldon is handsome from a production standpoint but it needs a little more Whipped Cream. By that we mean where Alexei Ratmansky tended to indulge in a few too many steps, Wheeldon could have used a lot more. The choreography was thin in places due in part to Wheeldon’s effort to literally transcribe Laura Esquivel’s story text into movement. We got theatrical movement but not ballet. The problem was exacerbated by Joby Talbot’s cinematic score that does not provide a strong architecture in which narrative choreography can be embedded. The score lacks the dramatic range that would allow it to stand on its own as a musical work despite its extravagance and Mexican-themed rhythms. A score that is too weak to stand on its own and make its own statement is not going to lift up a ballet. At one point, a sudden burst of horns and percussion shouted excitement and then stopped like maybe Anthony Quinn had arrived in Viva Zapata! Too cinematic, too telenovela-like, too backgroundish. A ballet score is never background music to the dancing or to any of the action on stage. It is an integral part, an impetus, a controlling, motivating partner in the ballet. Balanchine reportedly once said, “It is the music that dictates the whole shape of the work."
 
        In a nutshell, the LWFC story conveys the traditional obligation of the youngest daughter to withhold marrying in order to take care of her mother through the end of life. This particular youngest daughter, however, falls in love and wants to marry. She is as hot for her man as water for making hot chocolate. The mother salvages the daughter's traditional obligation by insisting that the youngest daughter’s suitor marry the eldest sister instead. Then there are side plots. Then there are side plots. Then there are side plots. 
 
        The “staging” and production aspects of LWFC make it worthy of continued revising and editing. There were some fine individual performances and corps work but not enough to make a fulfilling evening of ballet.
 
        The character Nacha, the family cook, which was performed by Courtney Lavine was perhaps the most dramatically interesting of the 25 or so roles. The stage movement given to her by Wheeldon had a 1940s type intensity that was common in Graham and Tudor works. Lavine was riveting during every second of it. The affecting beauty of her face read strongly from the Met stage during the first scene. Overwhelming was the haunting poignancy of her spirit form which reappeared on occasion thereafter.
 
        The character of Mama Elena, portrayed by Claire Davison, felt “off” in some ways. She was more of a wicked stepmother who antagonized her youngest daughter from the outset even though she expected her to take care of her until the mother died. What was the impetus for the brutal attitude? In this world, did mothers always automatically hate their youngest daughters from the gitgo? There should have been some emotional conflict in Mama Elena’s character. Was there no guilt about destroying her youngest’s happiness for her own selfish needs?
 
        The middle daughter, Gertrudis (Skylar Brandt), and the revolutionary soldier Juan Alejandrez (Aran Bell) received meaningful choreographic attention from Wheeldon. A wild orgy set off by the aphrodisiac effect of some rose petals innocently dropped into a quail roast and then served to guests provided Brandt with some of the most entertaining dance opportunities of the evening. She and Bell appearing in the Act II fiesta threw an entire evening’s energy into their spirited struts, stomps, and seductions. These same scenes that allowed the corps de ballet to take over the stage were without a doubt the best dance sequences of the evening.
 
        The eldest daughter, Rosaura (Chloe Misseldine), enjoyed less clarity in character. Her choreography was not particularly memorable although her striking beauty certainly was.
 
        Our main characters, Tita and Pedro, were touchingly portrayed by Sunmi Park and Daniel Camargo. We could tell they were in love and in a vexing predicament. Both are beautiful classical dancers but had little opportunity to show it. Their PdDs were the twisty, acrobatic, tiresome manipulations sometimes re-hashed from other Wheeldon works. Apologies for Haglund’s audible groan when Camargo picked up Park from behind and she grabbed one outstretched leg with both hands like it was a shotgun. How many times have we seen this in the choreographer’s dances — too many. Their PdDs seemed to ramble on and on as the musical rhythms tumbled along without arcs or drama. There was nothing objectionable about anything that they danced; the choreography simply wasn’t meaty enough. To circle back, the music simply didn’t challenge Wheeldon to do anything other than what he has done before.
 
        The final tableau of the two lovers figuratively going up in flames as they "transcended the mortal realm" brought some oohs & aahs. Upon exiting, Haglund overheard “I thought you were bringing me to the ballet.” Expectations perhaps not met.
 
        The H.H. Pump Bump Award, a colorful Louboutin stiletto, is bestowed upon Courtney Lavine for her haunting portrayal of Nacha.
 
Image 6-29-23 at 10.21 PM
 
 
 

 

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10